The cricket thread

scrumhalf · August 2019

Broad's second over - a thing of beauty.

munckee · August 2019

12 runs 1 wicket - rain break.

RandallFlagg · August 2019

Early wicket from Jofra, nice start.

Heartfeltdawn · August 2019

crunchman said:
DIdn't he miss some time because of the illness?

He was a great player. As well as being an all time great batsman, he was a superb fielder, and also a very useful bowler. He actually opened the bowling on one tour of South Africa. He got good batsman like Bradman and McCabe out as well.

He missed the entire 1926 season.

octatonic · August 2019

RandallFlagg said:

Early wicket from Jofra, nice start.

Not for me.

earwighoney · August 2019

Another decision overturned, a truly horrific piece of umpiring from Chris Gaffaney. Huge clunk wooden sound for an edge, originally given not out.

How on earth was it missed or considered to be coming off the pad?

scrumhalf · August 2019

To be fair to the umpire there was a fair bit of crowd noise, cheering Bo Peep going after her/his inflatable sheep.

RandallFlagg · August 2019

Ah the ebb and flow of Test cricket, a flurry of quick wickets for England and things look more balanced again 141-5

scrumhalf · August 2019

I don't think Labuschagne will be doing much ebbing and flowing after that one. Can you have groinal concussion?

RandallFlagg · August 2019

scrumhalf said:

I don't think Labuschagne will be doing much ebbing and flowing after that one. Can you have groinal concussion?

He'll be resting the eggs on an icepack in bed later!

RandallFlagg · August 2019

8 down for 175 good stuff, get them all for 200 would be grand. Plenty of action today for Mark @guitars4you hope he didn't get too wet this morning!

Heartfeltdawn · August 2019

Y'know this whole England thing where players from Division 2 were deemed to be lesser quality somehow and never picked?

So far we have a Division 2 quick bowler wowing everyone for England and the Aussies have picked someone playing Division 2 CC this year to replace the BBSB and he's done very well indeed on two tough wickets.

Is the gap in quality between 1 and 2 less than it was before? I think it is.

*best batsman since Bradman

scrumhalf · August 2019

Nine down and I think play ends at 7:30, so not enough time to bat tonight (and for Roy to be out).

crunchman · August 2019

Heartfeltdawn said:

*best batsman since Bradman

I assume you are being tongue in cheek there.

He's not even the best Australian batsman. If anyone invents a time machine, I'd like to see how he would get on against the 1983-4 Windies. I doubt he would have averaged 74 like AB did.

RandallFlagg · August 2019

That's a batting collapse England would be proud of:

Batsman	How Out	Bowler	Runs
Total	(52.1overs)	179 all out
Warner	cBairstow	bArcher	61	148	94	7	0
Harris	cBairstow	bArcher	8	18	12	2	0
Khawaja	cBairstow	bBroad	8	21	17	1	0
Labuschagne	lbw	bStokes	74	215	129	10	0
Head		bBroad	0	8	6	0	0
Wade		bArcher	0	9	3	0	0
Paine	lbw	bWoakes	11	48	26	1	0
Pattinson	c Root	bArcher	2	15	8	0	0
Cummins	cBairstow	bArcher	0	19	13	0	0
Lyon	lbw	bArcher	1	14	4	0	0
Hazlewood	not out		1	5	3	0	0
Extras	2nb 5w 4b 2lb		1

Heartfeltdawn · August 2019

crunchman said:

Heartfeltdawn said:

*best batsman since Bradman

I assume you are being tongue in cheek there.

He's not even the best Australian batsman. If anyone invents a time machine, I'd like to see how he would get on against the 1983-4 Windies. I doubt he would have averaged 74 like AB did.

I'm as tongue in cheek regarding the BBSB as Morrissey was hand in glove.

earwighoney · August 2019

Heartfeltdawn said:

Y'know this whole England thing where players from Division 2 were deemed to be lesser quality somehow and never picked?

So far we have a Division 2 quick bowler wowing everyone for England and the Aussies have picked someone playing Division 2 CC this year to replace the BBSB and he's done very well indeed on two tough wickets.

Is the gap in quality between 1 and 2 less than it was before? I think it is.

*best batsman since Bradman

A LOL and I'd wis you as well. BSBB is a clear joke, good acronym as well.

In agreement about the gap in quality between 1 & 2.

octatonic · August 2019

Bugger.

NorthernGooner · August 2019

So the two best players on either side today were ringers. Their Saffa and our West Indian.

Labuschange has had the whole summer to go round the English county circuit developing a technique
to cope with batting conditions here. ECB are mad to let this happen. Called into the Aussie test team and he's quite at home thank you. If you take players who have scored over 1,000 runs this season he's top of the averages.
Surely the purpose of county cricket should be to make the test team stronger, not give extended practice opportunities to the opposition. If an England player tried to get game time in Sheffield Shield cricket, he'd be told thanks but no thanks.

guitars4you · August 2019

RandallFlagg said:

8 down for 175 good stuff, get them all for 200 would be grand. Plenty of action today for Mark @guitars4you hope he didn't get too wet this morning!

Great day and stayed dry - Under the new 'Football Stand/Emerald Stand' that backs onto the Rhinos pitch - So by the wicket at almost fine leg and facing the pavilion - Top tier

Enjoyed it - Although at 120ish for 2 I was a bit worried - Stokes and Woakes lost the plot - Not sure why it took Root so long to take them both of, considering Broad/Archer were still fresh - But good recovery

Great fun on the adjoining 'Western Terrace' during any breaks inc the rain - 10/20 playing a fun game of cricket on a walk way - Most in fancy dress - soft ball - rubbish bin for stumps - Got loads of cheers from adjoining fans, especially if the ball when on the 'pitch' and of course the 'Little Hitlers' did not want to return the ball

iseverynamegone · August 2019

I reckon if I batted at 4 for Australia I’d get a nice half century.

Root must be relieved , good come back from the bowling unit - though broad bowled beautifully all day.

Bright sunshine with any luck tomorrow, if we bat poorly all the hard work will be undone and goat will get us 4th innings.

scrumhalf · August 2019

Well at least we don't have the risk of following on.

Apparently Buttler and Bairstow have swapped places in the batting order. Perhaps Leach and Roy might also be considered.

Looking forward to another day's absorbing test cricket.

RandallFlagg · August 2019

Cometh the hour cometh the man. Jason Roy your time to bat is nigh, get out there, know where your off stump is by putting your head and front foot in line with it and leave the balls you don't need to hit until the ball goes off then make hay in the afternoon. Get it done, we want a 3 figure score.

guitars4you · August 2019

RandallFlagg said:

Cometh the hour cometh the man. Jason Roy your time to bat is nigh, get out there, know where your off stump is by putting your head and front foot in line with it and leave the balls you don't need to hit until the ball goes off then make hay in the afternoon. Get it done, we want a 3 figure score.

A good 50 plus from Roy today and a ton plus from Root in this innings please

Heartfeltdawn · August 2019

NorthernGooner said:

Labuschange has had the whole summer to go round the English county circuit developing a technique
to cope with batting conditions here. ECB are mad to let this happen. Called into the Aussie test team and he's quite at home thank you. If you take players who have scored over 1,000 runs this season he's top of the averages.
Surely the purpose of county cricket should be to make the test team stronger, not give extended practice opportunities to the opposition. If an England player tried to get game time in Sheffield Shield cricket, he'd be told thanks but no thanks.

Overseas players have played in the Sheffield Shield so your final sentence isn't accurate. The scheduling of the SS and financial considerations are a far bigger factor as to why there are no to few overseas players.

One of the reasons we won in 2005 was through having a County Championship system that had good foreign players coming up against English ones. Good cricket was played and so we had players who didn't have stellar county records coming into the England side and performing well. Removing overseas players if their countries are playing over here in the same season would be utterly daft.

So the failure isn't that we've given an Australian a chance to get used to English and Welsh conditions. The failure is that we have created a system that actually disadvantages English players as those who play the limited overs format as well as Test cricket do not get more time in the middle at FC level. This then leads to the ECB taking a punt on someone like Roy rather than picking someone who has been in form at FC level.

Compare Labuschagne to Jason Roy. ML comes over, focuses on 1st class cricket, works on his technique, is successful, and transfers into the Aussie team and scores runs on difficult pitches.

JR focuses on the IPL and 50 over cricket, hasn't played a FC game all summer outside of the Test arena, and looks like he's been found out already.

The Aussies are happy to pick a guy like Labuschagne after a county season with 1114 CC2 runs at 65 with 5 tons. The like of Malan (907 runs at 56 with 4 tons) or Hassan Azad (961 runs at 56 with 3 tons as an opener) don't get a look in with our selectors.

The system ain't broken because it allows Aussies to play here during an Ashes summer. It's broken becuse it doesn't let multi-format English players play here during an Ashes summer and leads to the selectors picking a guy ike Roy who has had a total of 10 CC innings from 2017 to 2019 (7 in 2017, 3 last year, 0 this year).

Heartfeltdawn · August 2019

RandallFlagg said:

Cometh the hour cometh the man. Jason Roy your time to bat is nigh, get out there, know where your off stump is by putting your head and front foot in line with it and leave the balls you don't need to hit until the ball goes off then make hay in the afternoon. Get it done, we want a 3 figure score.

Preferably in the one innings as opposed to spread over the entire series...

crunchman · August 2019

What is Roy doing?

At the moment, he's not a test opener in English conditions. Might be ok in India where the ball doesn't move much.

scrumhalf · August 2019

crunchman said:

What is Roy doing?

At the moment, he's not a test opener in English conditions. Might be ok in India where the ball doesn't move much.

He's walking back to the pavilion at the moment. It would appear that he thinks he's playing in a T20 game.

It's predictable and embarrassing.

crunchman · August 2019

Same as the one ten minutes ago but he managed to nick it this time.

Why on earth is he playing at those?

scrumhalf · August 2019

Shit. Root goes for a duck.

Howdy, Stranger!

Categories

In this Discussion

Become a Subscriber!

The cricket thread

Comments